I think scent is a very subjective thing, but in my humble opinion, the Art of Shaving Sandlewood scent is pretty hard to beat. Call it a guilty pleasure! I have said before that I recognize the fact that they don't get or deserve much Straight shaving street cred (at least for now this is the case) but, they have this scent figured out.
You can get a sample if you live near one or by calling them if you don't.
Good luck on the hunt! I will check back to see what you end up with as this is one of my favorite scents.
