[hoglahoo]

I was disappointed that John didn't take the opportunity to lighten the mood. I think he could have simply answered "yes." And when asked for an explanation he could have said, "Just you whoopi. Nobody else, just you."

I'd also like to point out that this video is worth watching even if you don't have sound. Watch Barbara - was she drooling or just bored?

YouTube - McCain says he's against strict constitutionalists on SCOTUS

[Mike7120]

This video really reminds of something. During my undergrad years in psychology I was several times accused of being a racist by several professors and students for merely showing admiration for the Founding Fathers (both Federalists and Anti-Federalists) and the Constitution. I remember having heated debates during class on this topic; this is when I first realized my true passion was in government, not psychology. I agree with you though, McCain could have “lightened the mood.” For me personally though, it gets rather aggravating having to repeatedly explain my position on constitutionalism to those that always make the remarks similar to what Whoopi just said.

[Bruno]

He could have come out of that a whole lot better if he indeed had lightened the mood.
And I also think his answer was wrong.

If the founding fathers had been all-wise, the constitution would not have to be amended. They were fallible humans so they weren't all-wise. Demanding that the constitution should be interpreted as the FF intended may be a good soundbite, but it's not what you want.

[LX_Emergency]

Originally Posted by Bruno

He could have come out of that a whole lot better if he indeed had lightened the mood.
And I also think his answer was wrong.

If the founding fathers had been all-wise, the constitution would not have to be amended. They were fallible humans so they weren't all-wise. Demanding that the constitution should be interpreted as the FF intended may be a good soundbite, but it's not what you want.

Bruno!! Did you just say that the founding fathers were only human? But they wrote the all powerfull american constitution that all other countries wish the had.

Sacriledge!! He's a with!! burn im!!

[jockeys]

of course he didn't try and lighten the mood. talking racial politics with someone of a different race than you are is about as lighthearted as tapdancing in a minefield.

obama might have been able to get away with making a joke there, but an old white man? no way. they'd have crucified him, and he knew it.

disclaimer: i am not a fan of mccain or obama.

[nun2sharp]

The whole reason for whoopi"s question was a backhanded approach that would suggest McCain as being racist, the suggestion is as good as reality in politics, she knows damn well that he isnt suggesting forced servitude. I will not vote for McCain or Obama so this is an impartial observation.

Oh man!! 999 posts, what should I do with the next one!? I dont want to waste it!

[Dicestone]

McCaing should have lightened thing up a bit by joking. "Woopie" You made so much money over the years you have nothing to worry about. You can always buy your way to freedom!"

[Dicestone]

Whow! I had two typo errors and a grammer error all in the same post. I should refrain from licking toads until after 3PM.

[jockeys]

Originally Posted by Dicestone

McCaing should have lightened thing up a bit by joking. "Woopie" You made so much money over the years you have nothing to worry about. You can always buy your way to freedom!"

that would have been complete and utter political suicide, especially in front of such a large audience with such an incendiary host grilling him.

[hoglahoo]

barbara momentarily losing control of her lower jaw at 0:13 cracks me up every time hahaha. I'm going to have to unsubscribe from this thread

[Bruno]

I have to change my earlier statement after reading Jockeys' post.
Making light of the situation could have been political suicide.
Depending on what he said, Woopi could have countered with 'Yes massa, shall I get you some tea' and that would have been the end of him.